Turkey's Court of Jurisdictional Disputes settled which courts hear appeals against KVKK fines, upholding a 850,000 TL penalty for a missing VERBIS registration.
Two rulings by Turkey's Court of Jurisdictional Disputes (Uyuşmazlık Mahkemesi), published in the Official Gazette on 8 November 2026, closed a long-running conflict over data protection fines: criminal magistrates and administrative courts had issued opposite final judgments on the same penalties.
What happened
In the first case, a gym that verified members at the door using hand-geometry scanning was fined 100,000 TL for processing biometric data. In the second, a company that failed to register and file with Turkey's Data Controllers Registry (VERBIS) was fined 850,000 TL. Both companies went to court. Criminal magistrates reduced the amounts, while administrative courts upheld them in full. According to Gazete Vatan, the magistrate in the VERBIS case had cut the 850,000 TL fine to 27,037 TL. The Court of Jurisdictional Disputes adopted the administrative ruling in both files and set aside the magistrates' decisions.
Why it matters
The rulings do not create a new penalty scale. They settle venue. Under the provision added to Article 18 of Law No. 6698 by Law No. 7499, appeals against fines issued by the Data Protection Board must be filed with administrative courts. That removes most of the uncertainty in practice, and it removes a tactic: counting on a magistrate to cut the amount is no longer a defence plan. With less room to manoeuvre after a fine lands, the work moves upstream to preventing it.
What this means for smaller companies
Per the Data Protection Authority's annual revaluation notice, the 2026 minimums are 341,809 TL for breaching VERBIS registration and notification duties, 256,357 TL for failing data security obligations, and 85,437 TL for failing the disclosure duty. The ceiling for these items is 17,092,242 TL.
What stands out is that neither case turned on legal paperwork. One company let its VERBIS record and filings lapse; the other chose biometric verification where a lighter method would have done the same job. Risks like these are settled in the field: which system collects which data, whether logs are kept, who can reach which folder. For construction offices, shipping agencies and logistics firms running staff access control, this is especially pressing.
What we recommend at Kamer Bilişim
- Review your VERBIS record and its contents. If you registered years ago, the data categories you declared almost certainly no longer match what you actually process today. Changes have to be filed with the registry.
- Audit any system collecting biometric data. Time-attendance terminals, turnstiles and fingerprint or hand-geometry readers are subject to explicit consent and a necessity test. If a card or PIN does the same job, biometrics are risk you do not need.
- Put your logging and access rules in writing. Who can reach what on servers and file shares, how long records are retained, where backups sit: these are the questions that come up first in an inspection.
We provide KVKK consulting, firewall and log management, and data backup services on site and remotely across the Anatolian side of Istanbul. If you want to go over where your current setup is exposed, reach us through our contact page.
Source: Gazete Vatan report on the rulings published in the Official Gazette of 8 November 2026; Turkish Data Protection Authority administrative fine notice.
Source: Gazete Vatan